Real news.A stronger Maryland.

MARYLAND HERALD


Maryland Edition

LATEST
Business

W-4 vs. W-9: Which Tax Form You Fill Out and Why

A W-4 tells your employer how much federal income tax to withhold from your pay. A W-9 gives a business your taxpayer ID so it can report what it paid you. Here is how each works.

City with high rise buildings under blue sky during daytime

A Form W-4 is for employees: it tells your employer how much federal income tax to withhold from your paychecks. A Form W-9 is for people paid as independent contractors, vendors or other non-employees: it gives the business paying you your taxpayer identification number so it can report those payments to the IRS.

The two forms are easy to mix up because both ask for a name, an address and a tax identifier, and both are handed to whoever is paying you. Their jobs are different, though, and so are the consequences of getting them wrong. This guide explains each one, how they differ and where people tend to slip.

What is the difference between a W-4 and a W-9?

The short version is that a W-4 controls withholding and a W-9 supports reporting.

According to the Internal Revenue Service, Form W-4 is the “Employee’s Withholding Certificate.” It lets an employer withhold the right amount of federal income tax from an employee’s pay. Form W-9, by contrast, is used to give your correct taxpayer identification number, or TIN, to a person who must file an information return with the IRS. The IRS lists examples such as income paid to you, real estate transactions, mortgage interest you paid and cancellation of debt.

Form W-4 Form W-9
Who completes it An employee Someone being paid who is not an employee, or someone opening certain accounts
Who receives it The employer The person or business requesting it
What it does Sets federal income tax withholding from wages Provides a correct name and TIN for information returns
Does it say how much tax to take out? Yes No
Current revision (as of Nov. 19, 2026, per the IRS) 2026 March 2024

The W-9 never tells a payer how much to withhold. It only identifies you. For the vast majority of contractors, nothing is withheld at all.

Who fills out a W-4?

Anyone who is an employee and receives wages. When you start a job, the employer asks you to complete the form so payroll knows how to calculate withholding.

The IRS says the form covers your filing status, adjustments for multiple jobs, credits, other income, deductions and any extra amount you want withheld from each paycheck. Many people fill in only the basics, but the form allows more detail for households with two earners, side income or other situations that make the default withholding too high or too low.

According to the IRS, the form is generally not sent to the agency. The employer keeps it on file for at least four years and must make it available for inspection, though the IRS notes an employer may be directed by written notice or future guidance to send certain forms.

Who fills out a W-9?

A W-9 comes from whoever is paying you as a non-employee. Typical requesters include a company hiring a freelancer, a business engaging a contractor, or a bank or brokerage setting up an account that will earn interest or dividends.

You provide your correct TIN, which according to the IRS can be a Social Security number, an employer identification number or an individual taxpayer identification number. For certain payments, the IRS says you must give it in writing and certify under penalties of perjury that it is correct. The W-9 includes that certification.

As with the W-4, the IRS describes the form as something you give to the requester, who is the one that files the information return. It is not something you mail to the IRS yourself.

How do employees and independent contractors differ for tax purposes?

Which form you fill out depends on how the relationship is classified, not on what you call the arrangement. The IRS looks at the degree of control and independence in the relationship, sorting the evidence into three categories: behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship. It says no single factor decides the question.

The tax treatment follows from that classification, according to the IRS:

  • Employees: The employer must withhold and deposit income tax, Social Security tax and Medicare tax from wages. The employer also pays its own share of Social Security and Medicare and pays unemployment tax.
  • Independent contractors: Generally, the business does not have to withhold or pay any taxes on payments to independent contractors. The contractor handles their own tax, which usually means making estimated payments during the year.

For the contractor side of that arrangement, see the Maryland Herald guide to how to file self-employment taxes, which covers Schedule C, Schedule SE and estimated payments.

What happens if you never turn in a W-4?

Your employer does not simply skip withholding. According to the IRS, without a properly completed form the employer withholds as if the employee is single or married filing separately, with no entries in the form’s steps for multiple jobs, credits or other adjustments. The same default applies if a form is invalid, for example because someone made unauthorized changes to it. If the employer already has an earlier valid form on file, it keeps using that one.

That default can leave too much or too little tax withheld, depending on your situation. A married worker whose spouse also works, or someone with a second job, may end up owing at filing time if the default is too low.

How quickly must an employer act on a new W-4?

When an employee hands in a revised form, the IRS says the employer must put it into effect no later than the start of the first payroll period ending on or after the 30th day from the day it was received. In practice, a change made today may not show up in your very next paycheck.

When should you submit a new W-4?

The IRS suggests reviewing withholding each year and after major life changes such as a new job, marriage or buying a home. Its Tax Withholding Estimator, which the agency says takes about 25 minutes and does not ask for your name or Social Security number, can produce results you can use to complete a new form. The IRS recommends checking withholding every January.

Can you claim exemption from withholding?

Only in narrow circumstances. According to the IRS, an employee can claim exemption only if they had no federal income tax liability last year and expect none this year. The exemption lasts one calendar year. To remain exempt, the employee must give the employer a new W-4 claiming exempt status by February 15 of that year. If they do not, the employer withholds as if the employee is single or married filing separately.

What is backup withholding, and where does the W-9 fit in?

Backup withholding is the main way a W-9 can affect your pay. According to the IRS, a payer must withhold at a flat 24% rate in certain cases, including when:

  • You do not give the payer your TIN in the required manner.
  • The IRS tells the payer that the TIN you gave is incorrect.
  • The IRS tells the payer to withhold on interest or dividends because you underreported them, which the IRS says happens only after it has mailed you four notices over at least a 120-day period.
  • You do not certify that you are not subject to backup withholding for underreporting of interest and dividends.

Worked example

Suppose a Baltimore freelance designer is owed a $5,000 payment but never returns the W-9 the client requested. If backup withholding applies, 24% of $5,000 is $1,200 held back, and the designer receives $3,800. This is illustrative arithmetic only; the actual rules depend on the type of payment and the payer’s circumstances.

The IRS says the way to prevent or stop backup withholding is to fix the underlying problem, such as giving the payer the correct TIN, resolving underreported income or filing missing returns. If a payer notifies you that your TIN is incorrect, giving the payer your correct name and TIN and certifying it is correct can usually stop the withholding. Any amount withheld is reported as federal income tax withheld on your return for the year you received the income.

What mistakes do people commonly make with these forms?

A few patterns come up repeatedly:

  1. Treating a W-9 as a withholding form. A W-9 does not set a tax rate. Contractors who assume tax is being handled for them can face a large bill, because generally nothing is withheld on contractor payments.
  2. Using a W-4 when you are not an employee. A business that asks a freelancer for a W-4 may be treating that person as an employee. The classification matters because employment taxes follow it.
  3. Letting a W-4 go stale. A form filled out years ago may not reflect a second job, a new spouse’s income or a change in credits. The IRS suggests checking each year.
  4. Forgetting the annual renewal for exempt status. An exemption does not carry over. The February 15 deadline applies each year.
  5. Giving the wrong TIN on a W-9. A mismatch between name and number is one of the triggers for backup withholding.
  6. Being misclassified. If a business treats an employee as a contractor without a reasonable basis, the IRS says it may owe employment taxes for that worker. Workers who think they were misclassified can look to IRS processes such as Form SS-8, which the agency describes as a status determination request.

Business owners setting up payroll or hiring their first contractor can find the state side of the process in the Maryland Herald explainer on how to register a business in Maryland.

Choosing the right form

Form versions change, and the IRS posted a September 2025 update on adjusting withholding for 2025 tax law changes, so always use the current version. If you are on someone’s payroll, the W-4 is your form, and it is worth revisiting when your life changes. If you are paid as a contractor or opening an account that earns interest, the W-9 is your form, and returning it with a correct name and TIN is the simplest way to avoid backup withholding. Neither form is sent to the IRS by you, and neither replaces your own annual return.

This article is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Consult the IRS or a qualified tax professional about your situation.

Sources: Internal Revenue Service